i have read this post over and over
i beleive they were great answers on both sides of that fence as well.
im fairly new here but here is my 2 cents.
at that point i may suspect he is holding a-9 or even aa but i think i make a call here, even if i lose the pot it makes a resounding statement, that would carry for the rest of the night.
i dont think i check the turn instead bet out 3/4 of the pot it says look "I got the balls to play this game", and reverses the onus on him asking him "Do YOU have the balls to look me up?" and this would apply to many future pots as well, hence setting the stage for a monster bluff, if you were so inclined.
understanding you though a case could be made in the reverse(ie "i can make a monster fold you really dont want to call me bluff) but do you really want people to know that you can be bluffed by a player who has probably set the stage for himself already.just because tight players "appear tight" dosent mean a lack of knowledge of position, and the "perceived" weakness you showed allowed for an attempt at the pot.
(but from prior posts you have written you fully understand that).
i dunno, folding here also brings about the problem of "getting paid" when you do hit a monster hand in later stages of the game, but if the pots are all small anyways you already have a problem of getting paid off, that being said i dont beleive many more opportunitys would arrise for you to get paid off if the table is that tight, making an even stronger case to make a call.
either way i think i lean in here and take my lumps.
meet me on the river we can dance the night away on your money.